Folks often ask me why I, a failed missional church planter who lives in a single family home in the exurbs with a low likelihood of moving into multifamily housing any time soon, is so profoundly struck by monasticism, both old and new.  I usually can’t answer the question in any other way than by saying, “I’m not sure yet, but I trust that God’s in this and as a good pilgrim, I can only choose to follow.”

God is up to something for certain.  There are too many people looking at intentional community and new monasticism for this to be a coincidence; the Spirit of God is at work.  Perhaps it is because, in any moment in history in which we’ve had strong Empire, monasticism arose as a counterbalance.  Perhaps it is because in the West we have easy-beliefism and a deep loss of community.  Where I fit into this, only time will tell.

Or maybe there is something more critical at hand.  Consider this possibility, written by Poser or Prophet:

Not that I know anything about this stuff, but I reckon that, if the global markets were to crash and we were to be heading for some sort of Great Depression at some point in the future then… well… then it makes sense for the Spirit to begin stirring now-ish in order to create communities of Christians who are learning how to share the basic elements of life, who are economically dependent upon one another, who are making connections across national boundaries, and who are trying to bridge the gap between the West and the Rest of the world.

A possibility, indeed.  In any case, God is at hand.

Oh, and thanks as usual to my friend Eliacín Rosario-Cruz, who shared another item from this blog on his Google Reader shared items feed.  I love Google Reader shared items…

8 responses to “★ Why is New Monasticism on the Rise?”

  1. Pat Avatar

    I agree, Eliacin. Empire is evil (and I do think we're in the midst of a powerful one, unlike Tony Jones and others).
     
    I am also concerned about celebrity in Christianity in general, but especially in the new monastic movement.  I read a recent blog post from a youth minister whose kids were very excited to get Shane Claiborne's autograph and to go to the same restaurant David Crowder was eating lunch at to get a glimpse.  Their reponses gave him pause, which I think is good.
     
    Then again, the cult of celebrity is a big part of our empire, so these things are intermixed.

    Like

  2. Pat Avatar

    Thanks for the comment,Tess.  I wonder if what we're seeing too is a response to the American approval of spirituality in general, and honoritng those who are trying to live out a practical one as long as the people doing so don't hurt others.  I also think that the Buddhist monastic perception is helpful here – what's the well known bromide, "when I see a Buddhist monk I see a spiritual person, and when I see a Christian pastor I see a business executive".

    Like

  3. John Avatar

    My wife and I are oblates at a Catholic Benedictine monastery because the Christ in the Desert monastery decided to allow TV cameras to film the time 5 men stayed at the monastery in 2006.

    Christ in the Desert monastery is located in New Mexico about 1,700 miles from our home, but it was Christ in the Desert’s willingness to allow the modern media to film its activities that caused my wife and I to do something we had not done before — drive the 40 miles to the monastery near our home and see what it was like.

    Our visit to the monastery that we had known about for 25 years was like getting a call from God.

    Like

  4. Eliacin Avatar

    thanks for the shout out.

    Now my concern is as with any social movement of resistance, once this new wave of new monasticism becomes the flavor of the month, it runs the risk of losing it’s prophetic voice and praxis become just another segment of institutional religion. The ways of the empire are very ingenious and can perversely (sp?) turn it’s own dissidents into players in the market capitalist way.

    Like

  5. Tess Avatar

    I think you’re right, something is happening. I know that monasticism is a Christian (and Buddhist) tradition, but I wonder if similar leanings towards community are happening in other faith traditions.
    Since making my petition to become a Benedictine oblate I’ve mentioned it to a couple of (non-religious) work colleagues and have not been met with the incredulity I expected.

    Like

  6. Pat Avatar

    Hi John – thanks for your comment! It's good to see that as monastic life is being made more accessible to folks that we're able to connect with it. There was a pretty popular BBC series not long ago that did something similar.

    Blessings on your journey!

    Like

  7. IRS Avatar
    IRS

    The people who are concerned with, worried about, and see an empire are the ones who have the most tenuous hold on reality; they substitute their fears for reality, they read all events as confirming their insane hypothesis, and they take their leftist maul and swing it around to attack every issue with the same blunt, dead, boring, and mindless force.

    When you crawl out of your political foxhole and see reality — instead of fevered Marxist dreams — then you'll have something to say. Not until then.

    Like

    1. Pat Avatar

      Hi IRS – Do you have thoughts on what the differences between empire and superpower are? Your perspective on that may be enlightening.

      Like

Leave a reply to John Cancel reply

I’m Pat

Passionate about the common good, human flourishing, lifelong learning, being a good ancestor.

Things I do: Engineering leadership; Grad Instructor in spirituality, creativity, digital personhood, pilgrimage.

Powerlifter, mountain biker, Gonzaga basketball fan, reader, urban sketcher, hiker.