I was thinking this morning about the transition from a Christendom church to a missional church. In the Christendom church, the church creates “holy” analogues to what’s happening in the culture: we have Christian diet plans, Christian music, Christian film, Christian t-shirts, Christian vacation properties. The goal is to provide a sacred alternative to the profane one out there in the world, and that this alternative will lead unbelievers into the reality of God and his church.

Perhaps we need to re-emphasize the fact that “Christian” isn’t an orientation or marketing adjective; it means “follower of Jesus, carrying her own cross, living the eternal life in the here and now for the benefit of God’s glory and mission”.

As an example – there’s still a huge amount of dialogue about whether or not U2 are a Christian Band. One of the presumptions behind this question is, “if they’re Christian, they’re on our side”, and another one is, “if U2 is a Christian Band, then it’s OK for me to like them and my kids can listen to them.” Books, newspaper articles, magazine stories and campfire debates rage about the topic.

But what if that question isn’t relevant at all, but the questions about U2 become more like these: “What does the music of U2 reveal about God?” “Does the social activism of the members of U2 display the life of God in Christ in ways that we can learn from and do as well?” And, perhaps most importantly, “what meaning do non-Christians find in the work of U2? Where are connections happening, and why?”.

If we looked at things like, “why is our culture so obsessed with horror and violence?”, instead of, “is that movie Christian”, would we learn more about how the story of God might actually become real to our neighbors?

6 responses to “What meaning does it convey?”

  1. Laura Avatar

    “why is our culture so obsessed with horror and violence?”

    This is an excellent question. Down the street from my house is a CD store. They have enlarged versions of the CD covers. I have often noted that every cover is angry and have wondered why. There is something to this.

    Like

  2. darren Avatar

    Good question to ask. I’ve been pondering the same by asking it in this way: What are the implications for accepting/following the stories told by the art and life of the artist?

    Like

  3. Pat Avatar
    Pat

    Laura – that’s the beauty of sociology to me 🙂

    That’s a good followup, Darren. I think there’s two perspectives at work – I’m thinking from the perspective of exegeting culture with my church for the purpose of communicating with the culture; from your perspective it’s more about what are the results for the individual’s decisions. Good complement.

    Like

  4. Beth Avatar

    Indeed. This is one reason we deliberately bracketed the “are they a Christian band” question for “Get Up Off Your Knees,” even asking some of our preachers for rewrites when the focus was too much on that in/out way of approaching the question, rather than on the art itself. The whole question betrays a fundamental misunderstanding of what art is and how it works.

    Like

  5. Pat Avatar
    Pat

    Beth, thanks for stopping in. That’s a great point about the nature of art. I have the book on my bookshelf and am looking forward to sitting down with it – soon, hopefully.

    Like

  6. Martin Harris Avatar
    Martin Harris

    Most all of the movies that come out that are of any note ( and I mean commercial note) have little to do with Christianity. They are for the purpose of entertainment and most people are merely entertained even by the most “Christian” movies (whether the entertained are Christian or not). One of the real problems is that we don’t have much of a market demand for movies that really move us closer to God, call us to be more like Him, inspire us to fill His mission, or teach us much about the reality of ourselves or Him. We could be much better off if we only put His truth into action and planted it deep in our lives. Let’s watch movies that inspire that.
    And I really believe we COULD have a market. It is there, lying dormant. Christians don’t speak out enough either verbally or with thier atm card and they are not willing to walk away from enough misdirecting entertainment to quell its onslaught onto our culture..

    I do see the tide changing, the dormant sleeper awakening. I hear it when I call Macy’s and hear “Merry Christmas”, or when I see a movie like Mel Gibson’s “The Passion”. I like to be entertained though, its much easier. Maybe I need the constant reminder (be nice now!) to balance the constant message telling me I really NEED to SEE this one. The constant message that says I need to see a movie because someone made a good one (entertaining) that flies in the face of seeing a movie that means something real.

    Just one of my never to be humble opinions.

    Like

Leave a comment

I’m Pat

Passionate about the common good, human flourishing, lifelong learning, being a good ancestor.

Things I do: Engineering leadership; Grad Instructor in spirituality, creativity, digital personhood, pilgrimage.

Powerlifter, mountain biker, Gonzaga basketball fan, reader, urban sketcher, hiker.